Pomegranate Hall was built in 1830 by Judge Nathan Sayre. Sayre, a New Jersey transplant, was a lawyer and intelligent real estate investor. He became a state attorney, member of the Georgia legislature, and a superior court judge. Though never marrying, Sayre had three children with Susan Hunt, a freed slave. Hunt was a mix of Cherokee, Caucasian, and African. For many years, they lived together in Pomegranate Hall.
Pomegranate Hall originally was situated on several acres, where Sayre had vineyards and pomegranate trees planted for making his wine. The home itself is granite and brick with walls two feet thick. It is believed the house was partially constructed in New Jersey and brought to Georgia in sections. The house was known to have false walls and a very unusual layout that included the kitchen on the bottom floor. The main floor consisted of an elaborate entrance hall, two reception rooms, and a library. Judge Sayre was one of few people of his time who challenged racial boundaries. In his library, he kept books arguing against the then common belief that racially mixed offspring are physically and genetically inferior. Among the volumes, Sayre kept in his library was the book by Alexander Walker titled Intermarriage; or, The Mode in Which and the Causes Why, Beauty, Health, and Intellect Result from Certain Unions, and Deformity, Disease, and Insanity, from Others. It was a rare book for this era that argued against the common belief that racial “amalgamation” would produce degenerate and physically inferior offspring. The children of Nathan Sayre and Susan Hunt proved to be anything but inferior. Their children and many grandchildren figured prominently in southern education and reform movements.
The front porch has a stairway on each side, and a balustrade runs along the front of the porch and down each set of stairs. Four massive Doric columns with fourteen sides on square pedestals support the front porch. Marble mantles and silver knobs gave the home a sophisticated feel. The multi-level house had several entrances, stairs, and cul-de-sacs. From the back of the house, all three stories are visible, but from the front, you only see two. Some believe this is where the name “Half House” came from. Under the porch, there is another entrance leading to the kitchen, but it is barely visible today due to the dense vegetation around the house. Some believe the complex layout of Pomegranate Hall was to support the equally complicated family dynamics. After the Judge’s death in 1853, the house was purchased by the Simpson family. They owned it when diarist Frances Andrews visited, shortly after Sherman and his soldiers burned everything just a short distance away.
In 1963, the widow of Oliver Macy (of the Macy’s Department Store family) purchased Pomegranate Hall. She was known to always wear all black and often walked into downtown from her stately residence. Ms. Macy lived in the house until her death in 1992.
Pomegranate Hall was purchased by Emily K. Hair, widow of the late historian Dr. William Ivy Hair. On July 5, 2001, during an argument with her son, Ms. Hair set fire to clothes in an upstairs bedroom. The fire spread quickly from the bedroom down the stairwell and into the furnace, engulfing the entire upper floor. In 2003, the current owner purchased the house from Steve Hair, who inherited it from his late mother. The renovation proved to be too costly for the new owner. Today, the floors have collapsed, and the house is covered in massive overgrowth. There appears to be no saving the once grand mansion known as Pomegranate Hall.